Would a Boeing 777 have a better chance of recovering from the situation which led to the crash of Air France 447 while travelling from Rio to Paris?
Air France Airbus AF 447 Crash
The AF 447 crash has a slight similarity to that occurred on a Boeing 777 flying from Perth to Kuala Lumpur in 2005. In that case, loss of correct flight instrument readings was attributed to the ADIRU (air data inertial reference unit). It caused the plane to climb through 38,000 feet as it pitched up triggering the stall warning as the speed decreased from 270 knots to 158 knots. The pilot was able to recover from this critical condition and landed safely back at Perth.
In the AF 447 case, the loss of reliable flight instrument indications was probably caused by the iced-up pitot tubes. In this unfortunate case, the relief pilot was not able to recover the stalled plane - probably due to contradictory airspeed indications inside a thunderstorm at night - this led to poor visual reference of the horizon (see video of AeroPeru Boeing 757 accident below - static ports being "blocked" by masking tape) and possibly an incorrect stall recovery technique.
So, as you can see, both planes do have its share of problems no matter how reliable the manufacturers had intended the planes to be. I was once told that it was almost impossible for the Boeing 777 ADIRU to fail in flight and that the Airbus planes being almost ‘uncrashable’ but Murphy law seems to prevail in the end.
Would a Boeing 777 have a better chance than an Airbus A330? Possibly. However, I believe Airbus has given instructions to have all the pitot tubes concerned replaced since.
In my opinion, both planes have their own strength - Boeing 777 and later have good 'hardwares' whereas the third-generation Airbuses have better 'softwares'.
In the final analysis, the key to greater air safety is more training in the flight simulator to reduce human errors.
PS. To check for any latest updates or postings, please follow my new Twitter at @CaptKHLim
If you like what you read, more stories are found in my book LIFE IN THE SKIES (Preview here) and you can purchase a copy here. To check for any latest updates or postings, you can follow my Twitter at @CaptKHLim or Facebook here