Ask Captain Lim

Sunday, 07 September 2008
Home arrow Airplanes
Sunday, 07 September 2008
Main Menu
Home
Welcome
Ask Me
Forum
Disclaimer
Privacy
Search
Pilot Career
Becoming a Pilot
Female Pilots
Education
Medical Examination
Eyesight
Height
Age
Interviewing Process
Aptitude Tests
Flight Simulator
Training
Technical Questions
Professional Pilot
General
Licenses & Ratings
A320 Training Videos
Salary
Job Opportunities
Flying
Air Travel
Airways
Ditching
Dr JB Lim's Corner
Emergencies
ETOPS
Fear of Flying
Flying on the Boeing 777
Flying the Plane
Medical
Profession
Aviation
Airlines
Airplanes
Airports
Air Crash
Air Crash Investigations .. --(Not for Fearful Flyers!)
Air Safety
Air Security
Humor
B777 Photo/Routes/Seats
Video
Stories, Truths & Myths
Weather
Air Turbulence
Contrails
Crosswinds
Icings
Lightnings
Night Flights
Thunderstorms
Windshears
Custom Search


Report a comment

Thank you for taking the time to report the following comment to the administrator of this site.
Please complete this short form and click the submit button to process your report.

Name
 
E-mail
 
Reason for reporting comment
 
 
 

Comment in question

Fly-by-wire between Boeing and Airbus

By: Kieron (Guest IP 60.50.84.104) on 01-02-2008

Hi Lim, 
 
Further to your comments on the FBW systems... These systems are always active as they form the only links between the control input of the pilot flying and the control surface. It is the protection system that is activated on take off. If the FBW the system only came on when the aircraft was airborne then the pilot flying would not be able to rotate the aircraft at the required Vr speed and thus would not take off. The "weight switch" that you mention is located in the nose wheel strut and is there as a safety feature to backup the onboard computer system.  
 
On most FBW airliners there are 4 computers, of which three are always on with one redundant. Of these systems, if one fails then the others can take over the failed computers system. So as you can see, an FBW REPLACES the hydraulic systems employed. One advantage of the FBW control system is that, if a control surface fails, like the ailerons, then the onboard computers can re-route the control input to other surfaces to produce the desired effect with out the pilot having to change the way he/she flies the aircraft. An expansion on the FBW principle is the FADEC system. 
 
On the subject of the APS, the Airbus philosophy of total protection, while it had its teething problems, is the best in the world. You take an A320, 330, 340 up and try and crash it. If all systems are working properly, then it should stay in the air regardless of what you do to it.  
 
Personally, if I was flying long distance, I would much rather be in an A340 than a 777 if an engine failed en-route. As that is one thing you have failed to mention, the safety aspect of having 4 engines over 2. Just so you know, I am cross qualified on, 737 classics, 777 and A320 through to A340. Of the transitions between aircraft, I found the transition from A320 to A330 the easiest as they use the same identical cockpit. 
 
Yours 
Keiron

 

» Report this comment to administrator

» Reply to this comment...

»  Go back to the article


mXcomment 1.0.8 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved


Latest Comments
Do I qualify to join...
piloting
pls i need ur urgent advise on pilot...
26/08/08 More...
By jibahmd

Singapore Airlines...
SIA cadet pilot programme india
Dear All, Is SIA planning to come to...
21/08/08 More...
By Lloyd

What is the best route to...
hi
Hi i want to be a pilot but not enough...
16/08/08 More...
By sam

A successful aspiring pilot...
Thank you.
Haha.. I see.. I thought it was some...
12/07/08 More...
By Ng Liang Quan

What are your views on the...
Boeing 747 crash in Belgium
I still have no information as to exact...
09/07/08 More...
By Captain Lim

What are your views on the...
Boeing 747 crash in Belgium
Thanks Capt Lim, I was thinking,...
09/07/08 More...
By Mike Hodson

A successful aspiring pilot...
What's 33x45
it is a maths qn....
08/07/08 More...
By killerdark

A successful aspiring pilot...
What's 33x45
33x45 should be a normal mathematical...
08/07/08 More...
By killerdark

A successful SIA Cadet Pilot...
Sources for Aptitude Test
"My advice to aspiring candidates is -...
30/06/08 More...
By Ng Liang Quan

A successful aspiring pilot...
What's 33x45
Hi there, May I ask what's...
30/06/08 More...
By Ng Liang Quan

© 2008 Ask Captain Lim
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.