Ask Captain Lim

Tuesday, 07 October 2008
Home arrow Profession arrow Why fly at such heights when it makes more sense to fly lower?
Tuesday, 07 October 2008
Main Menu
Home
Welcome
Ask Me
Forum
Disclaimer
Privacy
Search
Links
OnLine Stores
Pilot Career
Becoming a Pilot
Female Pilots
Education
Medical Examination
Eyesight
Height
Age
Interviewing Process
Aptitude Tests
Flight Simulator
Training
Technical Questions
Professional Pilot
General
Licenses & Ratings
A320 Training Videos
Salary
Job Opportunities
Flying
Air Travel
Airways
Ditching
Dr JB Lim's Corner
Emergencies
ETOPS
Fear of Flying
Flying on the Boeing 777
Flying the Plane
Medical
Profession
Aviation
Airlines
Airplanes
Airports
Air Crash
Air Crash Investigations .. --(Not for Fearful Flyers!)
Air Safety
Air Security
Humor
B777 Photo/Routes/Seats
Video
Stories, Truths & Myths
Weather
Air Turbulence
Contrails
Crosswinds
Icings
Lightnings
Night Flights
Thunderstorms
Windshears
Custom Search


Why fly at such heights when it makes more sense to fly lower?
 

By Capt Lim, on 14-06-2007

Favoured : None

Published in : Flying, Flying the Plane

Good afternoon,

I have a rather unusual question that I am unable to find a definitive answer to. From what I have found, a large amount of fuel is consumed just to get the aircraft up to cruising altitudes from ground level.

My question is, why travel at such heights when it seems to make more sense to fly lower? I realize, over land, the noise and building height is an issue as well as migrating birds but over water, it seems like there is little issue.

Is there an aeronautical explanation or element of physics that I am not aware of? Obviously the higher you go, the further you need to travel to go from point A to point B; the other benefit of flying low would be safety.

It may not be very comforting at that speed to drop into the ocean, but 30,000 feet is not all that comforting either. Maybe, turbulence is worst the lower you are or people are able to see how fast they are going, could be a concern.

If you would not mind, I would appreciate any insight you may have on the topic.

Thank you for your time.

Russell

Hi Russell,


The main reason why jetliners fly high is because it is more efficient and economical to do so. You can also see my explanation in my earlier FAQ
which I am restate below:

"At higher altitude, the temperature decreases. The colder the air temperature, the better it is for the jet engine as it convert fuel more efficiently at low outside air temperatures. Basically, the efficiency is directly proportional to the temperature differential. The greater that temperature differential is, the more efficient the engine.

Colder air is also good for jet engine operation. Colder mass means more air. Remember the principle of a gas turbine engine - it requires air to be sucked at the front, compressed, combusted then expanded and blasted out through the jet nozzle (a more simplistic explanation - suck, squeeze, blow and go!)

Further, when a plane climb higher, the air outside gets thinner and less dense. This has the effect of reducing the forward resistance.

So, overall, a gas turbine engine is more fuel efficient when operated at higher altitudes than nearer to the surface."

Yes, most modern airlines employ the computer systems to optimize the overall efficiency of their operations by taking into account various factors such as the price of fuel or forecast winds to come out with an optimum cruising altitude. More often than not, the best altitudes are in the region of 35,000 feet, NOT 10,000 feet or 15,000 feet!

It is not necessary true that the higher you go, the further you have to fly (theoretically, yes) but for a long journey, it is insignificant. Further, although the fuel consumption on the climb is high, but overall, is worth the climb. In fact, it is safer to fly high as you would avoid most of the turbulent clouds, get better communication range, and not forgetting, in the very unlikely event of loss of all engines, you have a longer distance and time to glide home :-( !

   
Print
Send to friend
Save this to del.icio.us

Users' Comments  
 
 


Add your comment
Name
Title  
Comment
 
Available characters: 600
 
  This image contains a scrambled text, it is using a combination of colors, font size, background, angle in order to disallow computer to automate reading. You will have to reproduce it to post on my homepage
Enter what you see:

   
   

No comment posted



mXcomment 1.0.8 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
< Prev   Next >


Latest Comments
What would the Etihad Cadet...
Etihad Cadet Pilot Programme
Hi sam, May I noe how days did...
02/10/08 More...
By spooks

What would the Etihad Cadet...
Request
I have recently applied for the Etihad...
02/10/08 More...
By tazi

What would the Etihad Cadet...
request
Hi sam, I must tell something about...
01/10/08 More...
By Hassan

ETOPS and CRM queries in a...
bad-karma
but wouldn't you get into the Captain's...
30/09/08 More...
By john

Flying Schools
Student
...
30/09/08 More...
By Nicholas

What would the Etihad Cadet...
Waiting period for Etihad
Hi Sam, Similarly I have applied for...
17/09/08 More...
By Mohd

Why a sailor can have tattoo?...
tatoos can be removed
tatoos now can be removed by laser...
31/08/08 More...
By Dev Kamal

Singapore Airlines Pilots...
Fleet size
Hi Captain Lim, Why is the aircraft...
30/08/08 More...
By YAP

Do I qualify to join...
piloting
pls i need ur urgent advise on pilot...
26/08/08 More...
By jibahmd

Singapore Airlines...
SIA cadet pilot programme india
Dear All, Is SIA planning to come to...
21/08/08 More...
By Lloyd

© 2008 Ask Captain Lim
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.